information kitchen sink
so, prompted by a (breif) discussion I had with a customer while I was extolling the wonders and benefits of .Mac, I gave a cursory glance at Plaxo. if memory serves, Plaxo made the rounds a few years ago when it was new. the idea is pretty simple - you install a plugin into your mail client (currently, Outlook or Outlook Express) and you use their servers to keep your contact data up-to-date. the twist is that your contacts are actually prompted to update it themselves. the idea is clever, since having your contacts manage the data about themselves minimizes errors. the problem is it only works with Outlook and Outlook Express, and only on Windows. (just like the problem with .Mac is that it only works on a Mac and with iCal and Address Book unless you get something like PocketMac.) there are some other problems with it too that may not actually be problems - problems like what format is the data stored in and how do I get at it beyond their web interface and Outlook (things I can’t check since I don’t have a running PC anymore).
so, what really needs to happen is that someone needs to implement a similar service that works with open standards. why not move data back and forth using vCal and vCard formats - pretty much everyone who matters supports them. bonus points if you make a plugin for Outlook (et. al), Entourage, iCal/Address Book/iSync, and Mozilla Thunderbird/Sunbird.
while we’re talking about calendaring, let me just say that iCal in the enterprise (or even in the I-need-to-coordinate-multiple-people-prise) sucks. iCal is great at what it does as long as you’re just scheduling yourself. once you get past that it’s less good - sure, there’s the capabilities (in iCal 2) to invite people (which involves sending everyone a nice vCal file - which in and of itself isn’t a bad idea) and to publish your calendar (which unfortunately is a read-only thing) but there’s not much else besides that. if I have a calendar published and someone else on my project needs to update it, they need to schedule it on their iCal and then send me an invite so I can put it on the “official” calendar. there should be a way to have a server (it can even be based on WebDAV) to do this - just have a folder that represents the calendar itself and then vCal files for each event. you’d still have the generate-event-invite-maintainer model for people who you don’t want to give calendar access to but everyone else should just be able to publish it to the server and everyone updates. speaking of I wonder how hard it is to write plugins for iCal..
June 20th, 2005 at 2:09 pm
I’ve gotten invitations from several people to go “update my address book” at various different services, though I didn’t realize that had client plugins to manage it all. The idea is great, but I don’t trust any of these companies to go enter all my personal data into their database.
As for what you suggested for calendar server stuff — ya might try checking out http://greenbytes.de/tech/webdav/draft-dusseault-caldav-05.html
July 15th, 2005 at 11:15 am
mrg - just to extend what you’ve already written. If two contacts are both Plaxo members, they can connect to each other. When two members are connected to each other, when ever Member A updates his information, Member B’s address book is automatically updated.
Obviously, the ideal scenario is where everone in your address book is also a Plaxo member and allowed you the ability to connect to them. Then your address book becomes self-updating. People only need to manage their own information, and the Plaxo service takes care of the rest.
July 16th, 2005 at 9:47 am
in response to stacy - right-o, and that’s one of the cooler things (and more glossed over by me
about plaxo. now, what’d rock is if there was a way to do that independant of the platform you’re on - Plaxo only works on Windows at the moment. IMHO, it should be pretty easy to extend this to the Mac by using an iSync plugin or something of that nature.
July 26th, 2005 at 10:13 am
Plaxo has just announced a Thunderbird client and we’ve had Outlook, Outlook Express and Internet Explorer client for a while now. So that leaves just the Mac.